[Spoilers] Character Opinions (Your favorite and why)

[Azuriazu]

This thread is for posting your opinions on the characters and your standings towards them.

In my case, after first seeing the game, my opinions were standing like so:

Mikan: 10/10
Silvie: 10/10
Kotarou: 9001/10
Risa: 10/10
Nadeshiko: -9001/10
Kuu: 10/10

In other words, I loved Kotarou to the maximum level.

After playing through Nadeshiko Route, here is now my standings.

Mikan: 10/10 (Still the best but...)
Silvie: 9001/10
Kotarou: 10/10
Risa: ??/10 (Since it WAS the Nadeshiko route)
Kuu: 11/10
Nadeshiko: 5/10

Now my love has turned to Silvie. Why? I don't really know why, but Silvie's innocence is just the most Moe and captivating HGGNNNNGGGHH ever.

I can't really assess the characters yet until I have played through both routes, but as of right now, I am totally into Silvie now more than Kotarou.

Mikan surprised the hell out of me during her blowjob H-scene, never imagined she could actually learn how to deepthroat, I was like WTF what the hell does Risa watch?!

[windrunner023]

I only wish that there were seperate routes for each pet as well as the human characters, because seriously, they deserved it and would give the game a LOT more replay value. But, as it stands, mine are;

Mikan: 12/10 (Cute, my favorite by far)
Silvie: 9/10 (Love the quiet types...)
Kotarou: .5/10 (I hate her voice, seriously. And she's not very smart, but I love blue hair 3)
Risa: 11/10 (Everything about her is awesome)
Nadeshiko: 2/10 (I still hate her after her route, just... so... unappealing...)
Kuu: 10/10 (Seems kind of slow, but beautiful)

[Mkilbride]

Nadeshiko: No appeal at all. Even as a Loli, she fails.
Mikan: Cute, but fails to arouse my interests past cuteness.
Silvie: Very cute, can seem kind of appealing, but the Loli-ness ruins her for me.
Kotarou: I liked her actually, she was cute, voice was odd, yet charming, and she had some appeal, especially since I'm Irish.
Risa: Mm, I liked her. She was abit TOO open about her sexuality, but yes, she had appealing moments and a good personality to boot.
Kuu: What I wouldn't do for her. That is all.

[Tsubasa]

Mikan: 10/10
Silvie: 9/10
Kotarou: 9/10
Risa: 12/10
Kuu: 10/10
Nadeshiko: /10

You know I went through the Nadeshiko route, liked her up till the ending.
Mikan was lovable from the very start and Silvie took some getting used to.
Kotarou is lovable but not my type of character.
Kuu was awesome and I wished I had a bit more of her in the main.

And Risa, after playing her route I declare her my favorite.

► Show Spoiler

And damn she looks good with only one pony tail 3

[nanaya_shinya]

Mikan: A puppy with some cat-like characteristics...ok.
Silvie: Cute, but that's it.
Kotarou: Responsible. I'd love to have someone like her by my side.
Risa: *blushes*
Kuu: She reminds me of a sister that I never had.
Nadeshiko: ...
Kaie: How did this guy get in here?
Seika: It's loli-LUVIA!
Kana: one word, imouto
Misa:

► Show Spoiler

she's dead...

[yell0]

Mikan: A puppy with cat-like personality...ok.

Orz... Mikan does not have a cat-like personality. You've got it all wrong... INFJ loli-dog. Honest, caring, naive (about certain things in certain situations), but incredibly bright when it comes to the things that matter. She has the same birthday as me!

I was rather disturbed I found myself being able to relate more to Mikan than Yuuichi.. so it made things feel kind of awkward/wrong for me at first.. but I got over it... Mikan is <3

Mikan 10/10 - <3 (Really who cares about the other characters?) I need Mikan only route...
Silvie /10 - Very hot, but kind of dumb...
Risa 9/10 - I like Risa because of the very good suggestions she makes throughout the game such as "why don't you just do them properly?" Unfortunately I failed to find her hot though... even though I had no problems sympathizing with her. She is also very perverted which gives her extra bonus points on personality.
Kana and Kuu - Excellent friends
Nadeshiko - Feel kind of bad for her.. hope she isn't too lonely... nice girl though... (haven't played her route yet)
Kotarou - She mystifies me a bit... I like her.. but she is rough around the edges and doesn't seem all that intelligent.
Seika - She needs to stop making silly suggestions such as asking Yuuichi to hook up one of his doggies with Kaie... She can take care of *that* problem herself! Don't involve me or my Mikan!

[nanaya_shinya]

fixed...

► Show Spoiler

(changed personality to characteristics) If her name, her favorite orange box, liking of corners and small places does not appear cat-like to you then you probably just missed a few details.

(''-_-)y-=~

Well, that's just about as much information I could give without spoiling too much. I also don't want to make this a discussion thread, so I'd just stop commenting on other people's opinions.

[Dreamwarrior]

In a way I would give them all a 10 except for Nadeshiko whom I didn't like that much.
But a Kuu only route would have interested me VERY much.

[redlar66]

Mikan: 10/10
Silvie: 9/10
Kotarou: 10000/10
Risa: 7/10
Kuu: 9/10
Nadeshiko: 9/10

I actually preferred Nadeshiko as a character to Risa, though Risa had better ero scenes. *sigh* If only Nadeshiko weren't a loli...
Kotarou was the coolest character in the entire cast.

► Show Spoiler

Especially when she "helped" you. The tiger moment was pretty cool too. There were some interesting possibilities there that the writing team didn't touch on, unfortunately.

I hope ivory is still in business, considering their homepage status right now. I'd like a sequel...or an expansion with more routes.

[nanaya_shinya]

I hope ivory is still in business, considering their homepage status right now. I'd like a sequel...or an expansion with more routes.

Wanko to Kurasou: After Stories ?

tempting... )

[Dreamwarrior]

I'd soo much would want a sequel too. With or without hentai content. For I kinda really loved the story. But sadly that most definitely won't ever happen.
But then,... someone should tell them that I want a Kuu route and as secondary you guys could get your Kotarou *g*

[Lawls]

Mikan: 1337/10 I got this game because of this dog
Risa: 6/10 I liked her at first but was disappointed that i had to go with a human for a rout i just stumbled on hers and she just cam off as some ecchi chick
Kuu: 7/10 kept running in to her when trying to find kotarou
Kotarou:9/10 didn't like at first but she grew on me and i got into her
Nadeshiko: /10 course old lady plus loli didn't go well for me but did better than cliche ecchi teen have to do her rout now
Silvie: 9/10 I thought I already had a dog? but cute
Kaie: NA/NA so why were you here? (though wouldn't mind a scene with seika)

i omit the young students since you have nothing but random dialog with them.

and nanaya_shinya is that a clannad reference? XD

[Hoshiko]

Mikan: f(u) where u=infinity. very very very very lovable.
wish i had someone like this close to me. or if i ever have a daughter i might even name her mikan haha.

Risa: 9/10 very lovable and realistic. xD. first time i saw a girl in a VN who watches porn

Kuu: 7/10 very cute

Kotarou:9/10 had a good story

Nadeshiko: 4/10 didnt really like her. from the start until the end

Silvie: 9/10 LOLI. and very cute xD

Kaie: NA/NA so why were you her? (though wouldn't mind a scene with seika)

[pluckydono]

( ( (( BUMP )) ) )

Ok, so no one has bumped this thread in a bit..but I just recently discovered this VN and just had to share my opinion.

1= Hated | 5= Neutral | 10= Loved

Yuuichi 7/10 - He may be the main character, but overall he wasn't quite what he could've been. Although I did like some of his character traits.
Kotarou 10/10 - What can I say? She's both cute and sexy. While she may not be as smart as say Mikan or Kuu, she is one of the best supporting roles
[tab=100]down either Risa's or Nandeshiko's route. I also love the way she conveys her feelings without saying much.
Silvie /10 - She was incredibly cute, in a shy way. Almost too beautiful though...she seemed like a porcelain doll at times. I did like her character
[tab=100]down Risa's path better, because she was more dependable...perhaps even a bit smarter.
Nandeshiko: 5/10 - I like how she feels like a mature older sister/mother type. Down Risa's path she seems almost "tacked" on the story..but maybe
[tab=100]its because you don't see her much. Down Nandeshiko's path she's much more interesting and even a bit sorrowful.
[tab=100]

► Show Spoiler

She likes her saki though. ^_^

Kana 9/10 - Kana is cute, and has such an adorable relationship with Yuuichi, since he's her...

► Show Spoiler

"...valuable snack source."

Kuu 9/10 - Very smart, smoking hot, and even a bit sly. Offers good advice and even helps out her master's friends when they're in trouble!?
Mikan 10/10 - Without a doubt the best character. She tries so hard to be a good dog for Yuuichi; she's cute, lovable, and incredibly innocent. ^_^
[tab=80]Especially down Risa's path you're brought to tears ...

► Show Spoiler

because your so happy when you're reunited with Mikan. T_T

Seika /10 - Was surprised when she...

► Show Spoiler

...reacted to Yuuichi's pheromones. Though it was cute to see she had a crush on him through out the VN

Risa 6/10 - Risa's H scenes were great, but they also got kinda dull and boring because of how often they occurred. I did like the fact that she was so
[tab=80]open about her ecchi.
Misa N/A -

► Show Spoiler

Poor Misa. Leaving Risa and Mikan all alone by dieing. Though the main plot wouldn't have been brought together so well otherwise

Kaie: 4/10 - Was a bit upset that he wasn't treating Kotarou fairly, even though she wasn't necessarily treating him fairly either. He seemed nice, but
[tab=80]his H scenes were not necessary either. Though to be honest he was under a lot of pressure, not just from his lineage, but his profession
[tab=80]as well.