that one guy wrote:Story is nowhere near the same. Shirou has almost endless joy in most routes. Pretty much every Route of Tsukihime leaves you sad in some way, some girl has a horrible life if you choose another girl, ect. This does not happen in Fate / Stay Night.(Sakura does not count, because the HGW was over and she'd be mostly useless after all that to Zouken)
Something I was thinking about, Shiki really ****s up their lives. I mean, Ciel is the only one who was messed up before and might lead a messed up life after without Shiki. Arc? She's be just fine going about her business. Akiha? She'd continue leading her life as it was. Hisui? Same deal. Kohaku? Well...we all know about Kohaku. Her life sucks regardless. And, assuming that Kohakus route isn't cannon, Ciels dream comes true regardless. All is well for most of them in all the routes.
... but in the end they're all in love?... uh... yeah, let's go w/ that.
but seriously, ****s up their lives? he just happened to break the stagnation they were ALL in. arcueid would've been bound to an eternity of being an emotionless executor. teaching her emotions is ****ing up her life now? ciel will never die and always be seen as a monstrosity. he changed that. akiha kept bearing the pain of having to share half her life, and was approaching her limit. how is that leading her life as it was? hisui and kohaku had to play each other's roles. they weren't allowed to be themselves. they weren't allowed to express their true selves. shiki fixes that. tell me how in ANY of those cases is shiki ****ing up ANYONE'S life.